209 Old Ballentine Way

Holly Springs, NC 27540

This is not your typical Holly Springs home. Set on an impressive .76-acre homesite, 209 Old Ballentine Way offers 3,376 square feet, 4 bedrooms, 4 full baths, exceptional outdoor living, an incredible conditioned 3-car garage—and no city property taxes. Built in 2019, the home welcomes you with a soaring two-story foyer with wainscoting. A formal dining room features a true coffered ceiling and wainscoting, while the open-concept living area centers around a spacious great room with gas fireplace and beautifully appointed gourmet kitchen. The kitchen delivers with custom cabinetry, quartz countertops, 36-inch KitchenAid cooktop, built-in wall oven, microwave/convection oven, KitchenAid dishwasher, pot filler, and direct-vented range hood. A dedicated instant hot-water system serves the kitchen sink, and the walk-in pantry features wood shelving and a sliding pocket door. A bay-window breakfast nook overlooks the backyard. The main level offers the rare convenience of two private bedroom suites. The primary retreat features a panoramic bay window, spacious bath with separate water closet, and oversized walk-in closet with custom wood shelving. A separate in-law/guest suite includes a full bath with tiled walk-in shower—ideal for guests or multigenerational living. A custom laundry room and built-in mudroom drop zone complete the main level. Oak-tread hardwood stairs lead upstairs to a large loft/family room and two generously sized bedrooms. One offers the flexibility of a second primary suite, with vaulted ceiling, separate sitting room, walk-in closet, and private bath, while the other features its own walk-in closet. A fourth full bath rounds out the second floor. Four walk-in attics provide approximately 870 additional square feet of storage. Outdoor living is equally impressive. The enclosed four-season sunroom with EZE-Breeze windows features a wall-mounted electric fireplace/heater and TV connections. An additional open deck overlooks the private backyard, complemented by separate grilling and firepit patios. The fenced yard features TifTuf Bermuda sod and extends to the wooded edge, while the .76-acre property continues well beyond the fence. A storage shed with additional concrete pad adds even more utility. And then there's THE GARAGE. The oversized 3-car garage is heated, cooled, and EV/RV ready, with two 50-amp outlets and one 30-amp outlet, plus a utility sink, hose connections, hot-water spigot, Wi-Fi-enabled wall-mounted garage door openers, and an integrated ceiling lift for removing or storing a Jeep or convertible top. Additional upgrades include Lutron smart lighting with Alexa voice control, exterior architectural/landscape lighting, HardiePlank siding, Aprilaire crawlspace dehumidifier, integrated TAEX pest-control system, and annually maintained termite warranty. The Wi-Fi-enabled water heater was replaced in 2023 and includes leak detection with automatic shutoff. A proactively installed radon mitigation system, underground downspout extensions, and transferable structural warranty add further peace of mind. And perhaps one of the best surprises: No city property taxes. Located outside Holly Springs city limits while remaining in Wake County and served by Wake County Public Schools. 3,376 SF. .76 acres. Four bedrooms. Four full baths. Two main-level bedroom suites. 870± SF of walk-in attic storage. Conditioned 3-car garage. Exceptional indoor-outdoor living. No city property taxes. 209 Old Ballentine Way is the kind of home that's difficult to replicate—and even harder to outgrow.

Listing courtesy of Matthew Tirgrath of NorthGroup Real Estate, Inc.



Listings that are marked with an icon are provided courtesy of the Triangle MLS, Inc. of North Carolina, Internet Data Exchange Database. Copyright 2026 Triangle MLS, Inc. of North Carolina. All rights reserved.

Last checked: 2026-09-07 09:12 AM UTC